The Go-Around Call, the Stabilized Approach Criteria Every DPE Watches From the Right Seat, and the Student Who Keeps Trying to Fix What Cannot Be Fixed
Master the go-around decision using stabilized approach criteria from the ACS - the judgment skill examiners evaluate and real-world flying demands.
The go-around is one of the most failed checkride maneuvers that rarely gets discussed as a failed checkride maneuver. The issue is almost never flying skill - it’s judgment. Specifically, it’s recognizing the moment when rescuing a compromised approach is no longer the correct answer, and acting on that recognition before the runway makes the decision for you.
What Does a Stabilized Approach Actually Mean?
The Airman Certification Standards (ACS) define stabilized approach criteria clearly, and meeting them is not optional on a checkride.
A stabilized approach requires all of the following simultaneously:
- Correct glidepath - on or very close to it
- On centerline, or very close to it
- Target airspeed - for a Cessna 172, roughly 65–70 knots, with an ACS tolerance of plus or minus 10 knots
- Configuration set - flaps in the appropriate position for the approach being flown
- Power and pitch working together for a consistent, predictable descent
An approach that meets three out of five criteria is not a stabilized approach.
What Is the 500-Foot Gate?
The benchmark used by most flight training programs - and codified in airline standard operating procedures for decades - is this: if you are not stabilized by 500 feet above ground level in visual conditions, execute a go-around.
No hesitation. No “let me see if I can salvage this.” Apply power and fly another approach.
The reason 500 feet AGL is the threshold is not arbitrary. Below that altitude, you’re running out of time to fix anything meaningful. The runway is approaching fast. Corrections are getting larger, and each one tends to generate a new problem. Every second spent chasing an unstabilized approach below 500 feet is a second that could have been spent flying a clean go-around initiated a full minute earlier.
Some instructors push this gate to 300 feet. At that point, if anything falls outside the criteria, there is no evaluation, no assessment - you go around. Three hundred feet is not enough room to fix anything that actually matters.
What Is Your DPE Watching From the Right Seat?
Your Designated Pilot Examiner (DPE) is not watching just the last 300 feet. They are building a picture of the entire approach from the moment you enter the traffic pattern.
They are noting whether your power reduction came at the right point abeam the numbers on downwind. Whether your first notch of flaps appeared when you said it would. Whether you turned base at the right altitude and position to give yourself a reasonable final. By the time you reach 500 feet, the examiner already has a clear sense of whether the approach is solid or compromised.
What they do not want to see: a student who reaches 300 feet still high and fast, piles on full flaps trying to drag the airplane down, floats halfway down the pavement, bounces hard, and then goes around. That sequence is not a go-around. That is a go-around following a failed landing attempt - a fundamentally different thing in an examiner’s evaluation.
The ACS states the applicant must recognize when a go-around is necessary and must execute it in a timely manner. Those words carry significant weight. The examiner is evaluating whether you recognized the problem early enough to actually do something about it.
Why Do Students Keep Flying Bad Approaches?
Two specific cognitive patterns cause most go-around failures on checkrides: completion bias and the fix-it instinct.
Completion bias is the internal pressure to finish what you started. The runway is right there. Going around can feel like quitting - like admitting the approach was bad, which feels like admitting a mistake, which feels like handing the examiner a reason to fail you.
To be direct: going around on a checkride is not a failing item. Going around when it is the correct call demonstrates exactly the kind of judgment the ACS is designed to evaluate. Examiners are not marking you down for recognizing an unstabilized approach and handling it correctly. They mark you down when you don’t.
The fix-it instinct comes from training itself. The correct response to any deviation is to correct it - something drifts, you fix it. That instinct is right almost all the time. The problem is that there is a point on every compromised approach where the correct fix is no longer a small power adjustment or a rudder input. The correct fix is full power, appropriate flap management, positive rate of climb, and try again. Recognizing that threshold - the moment where rescuing the approach is no longer the right answer - is a skill that must be built deliberately. It does not appear automatically with more logged hours.
Does a Stabilized Approach Start on Final?
No. A stabilized approach on final starts on downwind.
The setup built in the pattern - the altitude at which you turn base, how early you extend flaps, the groundspeed you’re carrying - determines what you’ll be dealing with on final before you’ve made the turn. Speed carried through downwind does not disappear by rollout on final. Turning base too early and cutting inside the extended centerline means fighting that approach all the way to the runway.
The go-around doesn’t happen in isolation. It is the result of decisions made much earlier in the sequence. Students who build a disciplined, consistent pattern find that the go-around becomes the exception rather than a recurring event.
That said, even a well-flown pattern doesn’t guarantee a clean final. Wind shifts happen. Traffic appears. Things change. That is exactly why the habit of objective self-assessment at 500 feet matters regardless of how the approach started.
How Do You Build the Go-Around Habit?
Set a personal minimum and commit to it before the approach sequence begins - not on final, not in the pattern.
The brief is simple: If I am not stabilized by 500 feet, I am going around. No negotiating with yourself on short final. The decision is already made before the question ever comes up.
One practical technique that makes a real difference in training: call the approach out loud. Narrate what you’re seeing in the cockpit. On glidepath. On centerline. Airspeed on target. Continuing. And if something is off, say that too. High and fast at 500 feet. Going around. Verbalizing builds active, conscious monitoring instead of passive drift. Your instructor can hear you doing it right - that’s useful information for both of you.
How Do You Execute a Go-Around Correctly?
The go-around has specific performance standards in the ACS. Students sometimes make the right decision and then fumble the execution.
Step 1 - Apply power promptly. Full power, or the maximum allowable power for your aircraft. Not gradually. Promptly.
Step 2 - Establish a climb attitude simultaneously. Not level first, then climb. Immediately to the climb attitude - for most trainers, approximately 10 degrees nose up.
Step 3 - Manage flaps in stages. Do not retract all flaps at once. From a full-flap configuration, go to an intermediate setting first - typically the position your Pilot’s Operating Handbook (POH) specifies for the go-around procedure. Retract fully only after confirming a positive rate of climb with obstacle clearance ahead. Retracting all flaps at once at low altitude removes lift before you have the speed to sustain the climb.
Step 4 - Track the extended centerline on climbout. Climb out straight, as if departing that runway normally. Turn crosswind when you have the altitude to do so safely - typically near pattern altitude abeam the departure end. The DPE is watching your situational awareness and pattern work throughout the entire go-around, not just the first few seconds of power application.
It is not the student who goes around on a marginal approach who gets marked down. It is the student who makes the right call, flies a sloppy procedure, and fails to track centerline on the climbout. Make the correct decision - then fly the entire maneuver cleanly.
What Should You Do After a Bounce?
A bounced landing is its own trap. The natural instinct after a bounce is to push the nose forward and plant the airplane back on the runway. Resist it.
After a significant bounce, you are flying an airplane at very low altitude that is decelerating, with flaps extended and energy draining away. The correct answer is a go-around: full power, climb attitude, staged flap retraction, fly the airplane out. The runway behind you is not giving back what you spent. The runway ahead is running out.
The FAA Airplane Flying Handbook, Chapter 9 covers go-around and rejected landing procedures in detail. The Airman Certification Standards document lays out the performance criteria explicitly. Both are free at FAA.gov and worth reading in the original.
Key Takeaways
- A stabilized approach requires all criteria simultaneously - glidepath, centerline, airspeed (±10 knots), configuration, and consistent power. Meeting most of them is not enough.
- 500 feet AGL is the go-around gate in visual conditions. If you’re not stabilized by then, go around - no negotiation.
- Going around on a checkride is not a failing item. Continuing an unstabilized approach past the gate is.
- Completion bias and the fix-it instinct are the two cognitive traps that keep students flying compromised approaches past the point of correction.
- The go-around habit is built before the approach starts - brief your personal minimum on downwind and commit to it before short final asks the question.
Radio Hangar. Aviation talk, built by pilots. Listen live | More articles