The Gee Bee Super Sportster, the Granville Brothers of Springfield, and the Thompson Trophy Machine That Lived on the Wrong Side of Stability
The Granville Brothers of Springfield built the fastest racing planes of the 1930s, winning the Thompson Trophy twice while creating machines that killed nearly everyone who flew them.
The Gee Bee Super Sportster was the fastest propeller-driven aircraft of its era - and one of the most unforgiving ever built. Five brothers from Springfield, Massachusetts created a series of racing machines that dominated the National Air Races at Cleveland in the early 1930s, setting speed records that redefined what aviation could achieve while claiming the lives of nearly everyone who flew them competitively.
Who Were the Granville Brothers?
Zantford “Granny” Granville was the eldest of five brothers who came together at Springfield’s municipal airport around 1925. He opened a small aircraft repair and service shop, and over the following years his brothers joined him - Tom, Mark, Robert, and Edward. None came through formal engineering programs. What they knew about airplanes, they learned from airplanes.
By 1929 they were building their own designs: small sport aircraft, mostly biplanes, sold to private owners and barnstormers across New England. The company was called Granville Brothers Aircraft, and they stamped the designation G.B. on every product they made. Pilots and mechanics started saying it aloud. Gee Bee. The name stuck.
The early Gee Bees earned a reputation as well-built, reliable machines. What was increasingly evident was that the brothers had a genuine talent for eliminating wasted surface area and unnecessary drag. These airplanes were aerodynamically slippery in a way most contemporaries were not.
Then someone in Springfield looked at the Thompson Trophy results and started doing math.
What Was the Thompson Trophy Race?
The National Air Races at Cleveland in the early 1930s were a cultural phenomenon - part Super Bowl, part Indianapolis 500, spread across ten days above the Ohio flatlands every Labor Day weekend. The Thompson Trophy Race was the centerpiece: a closed-course pylon race for unlimited aircraft, ten laps around a roughly fifty-mile course at minimum altitude. You flew as low as you dared, turned the pylons as tight as you could, and kept the throttle up.
The teams that showed up were serious operations. Oil money from Texas. Factory-backed entries with aeronautical engineers behind every rivet. The Wedell-Williams outfit out of Patterson, Louisiana, running low-wing monoplanes built on genuine racing science. The speed records being set at Cleveland were the benchmark against which the entire aviation industry measured itself.
The Granville brothers showed up anyway. And they brought the Model Z.
How Was the Gee Bee Model Z Designed?
The design logic behind the Model Z was stark in its simplicity: remove everything that doesn’t make speed. Add engine until the structure protests. Keep the fuselage as short as physics will allow, because a shorter fuselage means less surface area, less drag, and more speed.
The finished machine looked like nothing else on the ramp. The fuselage was a fat barrel. The cockpit canopy barely rose above the engine cowling. The tail surfaces looked almost comically small for the size of the machine. Up front sat a Pratt and Whitney engine producing well over 500 horsepower, crammed into a nose so short it looked like a locomotive boiler mounted on a skateboard.
The tradeoff was deliberate. A shorter fuselage also means a shorter moment arm for the tail surfaces, which means less pitch and yaw stability, which means less margin for the pilot. The Granville brothers considered this an acceptable tradeoff. Put a good enough pilot in the seat and let the physics work.
The 1931 Thompson Trophy: Lowell Bayles and 236 mph
Lowell Bayles was that pilot in 1931. He took the Model Z through ten laps of the Thompson course and crossed the finish line first at 236 miles an hour. For September of 1931, that was extraordinary. The crowd at Cleveland went wild. The newsreel cameras got their shot.
Three months later, in December 1931, Bayles was over Lake St. Clair near Detroit, attempting to set a new world landplane speed record in the Model Z. At full power, low and fast over the measured course, the fuel tank access cover blew off and struck the windscreen. The airplane went in. Bayles was killed. It was the first death attached to a Gee Bee. It would not be the last.
What Made the Gee Bee Model R Super Sportster So Dangerous?
The Model R Super Sportster was the logical - and terrifying - extension of everything the Model Z had demonstrated. The whole machine was essentially a radial engine with a minimum of airplane attached behind it. The Pratt and Whitney Wasp up front was making around 800 horsepower in racing configuration. The fuselage aft of the firewall was a stubby, bulging cylinder. The wing mounted at mid-fuselage, right at the widest point of that cylinder. The cockpit sat so far aft that the pilot looked out over an enormous round cowling that blocked most of the forward view.
In the air, the Model R was what pilots of the era politely called a handful. What they actually meant was that the airplane operated on a knife edge of stability requiring constant, precise, deliberate inputs every moment it was airborne. The physics of a very short-coupled airplane with a very powerful engine and minimal tail moment are simply unforgiving. The slightest skid in a pylon turn, the slightest inattention at the wrong moment, and a pilot faced a snap roll at 270 miles an hour with 200 feet of altitude between themselves and the Ohio farmland. There is no recovery from a snap roll at that altitude.
Managing the Model R safely required a pilot who could fly in front of the airplane - not reacting to what it was doing, but anticipating what it was about to do and correcting before it happened. That required a combination of instinct, technical understanding, and an almost preternatural situational awareness that very few pilots in the world actually possessed.
Jimmy Doolittle and the 1932 Thompson Trophy
One of the pilots who possessed that ability was Jimmy Doolittle. The man who appeared at Cleveland in September 1932 was not yet the famous Tokyo raider. He was a 35-year-old test pilot with a doctorate in aeronautical engineering from MIT, who had spent years deliberately flying aircraft that behaved badly in order to understand exactly how and why they behaved badly. He understood the Model R technically in a way most racing pilots could not.
He won the 1932 Thompson Trophy at 252 miles an hour and set a world landplane speed record. He was the fastest man alive in a propeller-driven aircraft.
Then he walked away from air racing. He had a family, he said. He had made the calculation. He never flew a Gee Bee competitively again.
The Crashes That Followed: Boardman, Klingensmith, and the End of the Granville Brothers
What happened next is what happens when a machine designed around one specific pilot gets handed to others.
Russell Boardman, a skilled and experienced racing pilot, took the Model R out in the summer of 1933 for a practice session at Indianapolis. He crashed it badly and was critically injured. The airplane was rebuilt.
Florence Klingensmith entered the rebuilt racer in a race at Chicago in 1933. On the fifth lap, fabric tore from one of the ailerons. The airplane went out of control. Klingensmith was killed. She was 26 years old - one of the most accomplished women racing pilots of the era.
Questions arose about the structural integrity of the Gee Bee racers, about whether the design margins were adequate, about whether anyone should be flying them at all. The Granville brothers answered with modifications and kept working.
By 1934, Zantford Granville was dead - not in a racer, but in a modified Gee Bee sport aircraft at an airshow in Maine. He was in his early thirties. The company that bore his family’s name staggered briefly and then collapsed. The last of the Gee Bee racers, the Model Q, killed Cecil Allen in California in 1935.
Why the Gee Bee Legacy Matters to Aviation History
It is easy to look back and reach for the obvious lesson: hubris, recklessness, men who thought they could outrun physics. That reading isn’t entirely fair, and it doesn’t honor the people involved.
The Granville brothers were working at the absolute frontier of what aviation science could accomplish in their time. Wind tunnel time was expensive and limited. Computational tools did not exist. Stability and control margins were understood qualitatively, not quantitatively. The feedback loop between builder and pilot - fly it, tell us what it felt like at the edge, correct - was the state of the art. Everyone in racing was operating inside the same fog.
The pilots who flew these machines knew the stakes. They had seen what happened to others in other fast machines. They made their own calculations and climbed in anyway, because they believed that pushing the boundary was worth the cost of finding it.
Every speed record set at Cleveland moved the industry’s understanding of what was aerodynamically possible. The lessons wrung from the racing programs of the 1930s fed directly into the fighter aircraft that won the Second World War. The Spitfire, the Mustang, and the Thunderbolt all owe a measurable debt to the men and women who turned pylons at Cleveland for a trophy and prize money and a moment in the newsreels.
Where to See a Gee Bee Today
A reproduction of the Gee Bee Model Z is on permanent display at the National Museum of the United States Air Force in Dayton, Ohio, painted in the original red and white that Bayles flew to victory in 1931. It sits in the golden age gallery. In person, it looks improbably small - this fat barrel of a machine that could embarrass everything else in the sky of its era.
Key Takeaways
- The Gee Bee Model Z won the 1931 Thompson Trophy at 236 mph, flown by Lowell Bayles, who was killed three months later attempting a world speed record over Lake St. Clair near Detroit.
- The Gee Bee Model R Super Sportster pushed the record to 252 mph under Jimmy Doolittle at the 1932 Thompson Trophy; Doolittle then walked away from air racing permanently.
- The Granville brothers’ core design philosophy - minimize fuselage length, maximize engine power - produced extreme speed at the direct cost of stability and pilot margin.
- The Gee Bee program claimed the lives of Lowell Bayles (1931), Florence Klingensmith (1933), Zantford Granville (1934), and Cecil Allen (1935), among others critically injured.
- The aerodynamic knowledge generated by 1930s air racing programs directly influenced the design of World War II fighter aircraft, making the golden age pilots foundational figures in modern aviation history.
Radio Hangar. Aviation talk, built by pilots. Listen live | More articles