FAR Ninety-One Point Two Thirteen, the Inoperative Equipment Regulation That Decides Whether a Broken Gauge Grounds the Flight, and the Four Questions Every Pilot Needs Before Something Fails on Preflight

FAR 91.213 provides a four-question framework for determining whether inoperative instruments legally ground a flight or just require a placard and logbook entry.

Flight Instructor
Reviewed for accuracy by Matt Carlson (Private Pilot)

FAR 91.213 is the regulation that governs inoperative instruments and equipment in civil aviation. It gives pilots a structured, four-question decision process that answers - legally and definitively - whether a broken gauge requires canceling the flight or whether you can placard it, log it, and depart. Neither reflexive dismissal nor automatic cancellation is correct; the regulation gives you a framework to work through.

Does Your Aircraft Have an Approved Minimum Equipment List?

The regulation establishes two paths. No pilot may take off in an aircraft with inoperative instruments or equipment unless one of two conditions is met.

The first is an FAA-approved Minimum Equipment List (MEL). An MEL is a document developed with FAA oversight that specifies which instruments and equipment can be inoperative under defined conditions while still permitting continued operation. MELs are standard in Part 135 and Part 121 operations - charter operators, commuter carriers, and major airlines.

Most general aviation aircraft operated under Part 91 do not have an MEL. If you fly a Cessna 172 Skyhawk, a Piper Archer, or a Cirrus SR22, there almost certainly isn’t one aboard. That means the second path - the four-question test in subsection (d) - applies.

What Are the Four Questions Under FAR 91.213(d)?

All four questions must come back clean before you can legally fly with something inoperative.

Question 1: Is the Item Required by FAR 91.205?

FAR 91.205 is the required equipment regulation for civil aviation. It specifies what must be aboard based on the operation being conducted. Day VFR, night VFR, and IFR each have separate lists.

Day VFR required equipment includes:

  • Tachometer for each engine
  • Oil pressure gauge for each engine using a pressure lubrication system
  • Altimeter
  • Magnetic direction indicator
  • Airspeed indicator
  • Temperature gauge for each liquid-cooled engine
  • Oil temperature gauge for air-cooled engines where applicable
  • Manifold pressure gauge for altitude engines
  • Fuel gauge for each fuel tank
  • Landing gear position indicator (retractable-gear aircraft only)
  • Anti-collision light system
  • Safety belts
  • Emergency locator transmitter per FAR 91.207

Night VFR adds: position lights, a landing light if the aircraft is operated for hire, an adequate source of electrical energy for all required electrical and radio equipment, and one spare set of fuses or three additional fuses of each kind required.

IFR adds: a gyroscopic rate-of-turn indicator, slip-skid indicator, sensitive altimeter adjustable for barometric pressure, clock, generator or alternator of adequate capacity, gyroscopic pitch and bank indicator, and a gyroscopic direction indicator.

The turn coordinator is not on the day VFR list. The gyroscopic rate-of-turn indicator appears on the IFR list, not the day VFR list. So an inoperative turn coordinator on a Saturday morning day VFR flight passes Question 1. An inoperative altimeter does not - it stops the analysis immediately and the airplane stays on the ground.

Question 2: Is the Item Required by the Type Certificate Data Sheet, POH, or Any Placard?

This is where many pilots miss the full picture. Even if something isn’t listed in FAR 91.205, the manufacturer may have made it required for airworthiness.

The type certificate data sheet (TCDS) - the FAA document tied to the aircraft’s original design approval - can designate equipment that must be operative. The POH Limitations section may also declare certain items required for flight. If it appears there, treat it as required, because for that specific aircraft, it effectively is.

The stall warning system is the classic example. It isn’t named in the day VFR equipment list under FAR 91.205. But for most certificated aircraft, it’s listed as required in the type certificate data sheet. An inoperative stall warning horn isn’t a nuisance item - it’s a grounding item that Question 2 catches.

Question 3: Is the Item Required by an Airworthiness Directive?

Airworthiness Directives (ADs) are mandatory. If an AD requires a specific piece of equipment to be functional, there is no workaround under FAR 91.213. Flying with that item inoperative means flying out of AD compliance, which renders the aircraft legally unairworthy.

Know the AD status of any aircraft you fly regularly. If you rent, ask whether the school maintains an AD compliance log. If you own the aircraft, maintain one yourself. If the inoperative item is covered by an AD requiring it to be functional, the airplane stays on the ground until maintenance resolves it. No exceptions.

Question 4: Does the Inoperative Equipment Constitute a Hazard to Flight?

This question doesn’t come from a list. It’s a pilot-in-command judgment call.

Consider an inoperative outside air temperature gauge on a Cessna 172 Skyhawk. It isn’t on the day VFR equipment list. It isn’t designated required in the TCDS. There’s no applicable AD. It passes the first three questions. But if you’re planning a flight on a warm, humid afternoon where carburetor ice is a real concern, that gauge directly informs your risk assessment. Flying without it in those specific conditions could constitute a hazard.

The framework gives structure. The judgment is yours. No checklist substitutes for honest aeronautical decision-making.

What Do Deactivation and Placarding Actually Require?

If an item passes all four questions, two additional steps are required before flight.

Deactivation: If the inoperative equipment can be deactivated, it must be. A failed instrument showing a false reading can creep into your scan and distort your situational awareness. Pull the circuit breaker if one controls the system. Use any switch that disables it. Follow any POH procedure for deactivating a failed system. The goal is to remove the inoperative item from your active instrument scan entirely.

Placarding: The regulation requires a placard on or adjacent to the inoperative instrument or equipment that reads “INOPERATIVE.” This is not optional. It reminds you in flight that the instrument isn’t available, and it informs every subsequent pilot that the item is not operational. The entry goes in the aircraft logbook, the placard goes on the panel, and the chief instructor or aircraft owner authorizes continued operation in that configuration.

How Do I Handle Equipment That Fails in Flight?

The same legal framework applies in principle, but your options change once you’re airborne.

If a required instrument fails while operating in IMC on an IFR clearance, you have an emergency. FAR 91.3 grants pilot-in-command authority to deviate from any regulation to the extent necessary during an emergency. Use it. Declare the emergency if needed, accept vectors to the nearest suitable airport, and document everything for the required FAA explanation afterward.

If a non-required item fails on a clear day VFR flight, assess the failure, determine whether it affects your ability to complete the flight safely, adjust routing or destination if warranted, and squawk the item on landing.

How Do I Apply the Four Questions? Practice Scenarios

Scenario 1: The magnetic compass has a small bubble in the fluid. Still readable, but the bubble is there.

The magnetic direction indicator is on the day VFR equipment list. A compass with a bubble may still give usable readings, but its accuracy may no longer be within manufacturer tolerances. This is a maintenance squawk, not a placard-and-continue situation.

Scenario 2: Night cross-country. During runup, the position light on the right wingtip is inoperative.

Position lights are required for night VFR under FAR 91.205. Question 1 stops the flight. The airplane stays on the ground until the light is repaired.

Scenario 3: Day VFR flight. The cockpit clock has a dead battery.

The clock appears on the IFR equipment list, not the day VFR list. For a day VFR operation it passes Question 1. For most general aviation aircraft it isn’t designated required in the TCDS, there’s no applicable AD, and the absence of a clock on a clear afternoon isn’t a safety hazard. Deactivate it, placard it inoperative, log the squawk, and go fly.

Scenario 4: The stall warning horn is inoperative. Day VFR flight.

The horn isn’t named in the FAR 91.205 day VFR list - Question 1 passes. But the type certificate data sheet for most certificated aircraft lists the stall warning system as required equipment. Question 2 grounds the flight. This is exactly why memorizing FAR 91.205 alone isn’t sufficient; the TCDS and POH Limitations section add requirements the equipment list doesn’t capture.

How Do I Build Good Preflight Habits Around This Regulation?

When you check out in a new aircraft or begin renting from a new school, spend fifteen minutes with the POH Limitations section. Ask whether there’s an AD compliance log and what’s in it. Build a mental picture of what that specific airplane must have operating before it legally flies.

When something breaks on a Saturday morning, you’re not starting from scratch - you have context, and you work through the four questions from a position of knowledge rather than uncertainty.

If there’s ever genuine doubt about whether an inoperative item grounds the aircraft, involve a mechanic before flying. A ten-minute call to a trusted airframe and powerplant (A&P) mechanic is a far better outcome than a wrong judgment call.

Work through all four questions. Deactivate it. Placard it. Squawk it. Then go fly the airplane.


Key Takeaways

  • FAR 91.213 provides a four-question test for determining whether inoperative equipment legally grounds a flight or permits continued operation with a placard.
  • Most general aviation aircraft operating under Part 91 have no MEL, so the four-question framework under subsection (d) applies in almost every case.
  • The turn coordinator and cockpit clock are not on the day VFR equipment list under FAR 91.205 - both appear on the IFR list only.
  • The type certificate data sheet and POH Limitations section can require equipment not listed in FAR 91.205; the stall warning system is the most common example.
  • Any item that passes all four questions must still be deactivated if possible and placarded “INOPERATIVE” before flight - neither step is optional.

Radio Hangar. Aviation talk, built by pilots. Listen live | More articles