Eugene Ely, the USS Pennsylvania, and the Wooden Platform in San Francisco Bay That Invented the Aircraft Carrier

Eugene Ely's 1911 shipboard landing in San Francisco Bay - using sandbag-weighted ropes to stop his aircraft - invented the arresting gear concept behind every carrier wire in use today.

Aviation Historian

On January 18, 1911, a 24-year-old exhibition pilot named Eugene Ely made the first arrested landing aboard a ship - a wooden platform bolted to the stern of the USS Pennsylvania, anchored in San Francisco Bay. Using hooks fitted to his undercarriage to catch sandbag-weighted ropes stretched across the deck, Ely stopped his aircraft within a 120-foot platform. That system was the direct ancestor of every arresting wire on every aircraft carrier ever built.

Who Was Eugene Ely?

Eugene Ely was born in 1886 in Williamsburg, Iowa. He came up working with machines the way rural farm kids did in that era - with his hands, learning by doing. He taught himself to fly in 1910, which was not unusual in an age when formal flight instruction did not yet exist.

He flew as an exhibition pilot for Glenn Curtiss, the other dominant name in early American aviation alongside the Wright Brothers. The Curtiss lineage runs through some of the most significant aircraft in American history - the Jenny trainer of World War I, the P-40 Warhawk, the carrier-based Helldiver. Ely was operating at the beginning of that thread.

By all accounts, Ely was precise rather than reckless. The exhibition circuit attracted performers who confused bravery with the absence of fear. Ely calculated his margins.

What Aviation Actually Was in 1910

The Wright Brothers made their first flight in December 1903 - just seven years before Ely’s first shipboard flight. By 1910, aircraft were still built from canvas, spruce, wire, and iron. Engines ran hot and quit without warning. There were no meaningful instruments and no weather forecasts designed for pilots because there were no pilots to design them for.

The aircraft Ely flew was a Curtiss pusher biplane. Open frame. The pilot sat out front with nothing around him. The engine sat behind him between the wings, the propeller pushing from behind rather than pulling from the front. 26-foot wingspan. Around 500 pounds loaded. A water-cooled engine producing roughly 60 horsepower.

There was no windshield, no enclosed cockpit. At flying speed - around 40 to 50 miles per hour - the wind hit the pilot full in the face. In November at Hampton Roads, that meant cold air, fogging goggles, and stiffening hands on the controls.

The Naval Officer Who Made It Happen

Captain Washington Irving Chambers was the Navy officer assigned to study what airplanes might mean for sea power. It was not a prestigious posting. Senior officers thought he was wasting their time.

Chambers saw the strategic logic clearly. A scout aircraft could see over the horizon, identify enemy ships before the enemy knew you were looking, and completely change the intelligence picture for a fleet at sea. The problem was equally plain: ships do not come with airfields, and you cannot stop a fleet somewhere convenient just because a scout plane needs to land.

Chambers approached Curtiss. Curtiss agreed to supply the aircraft and the pilot. Ely agreed to fly.

November 14, 1910: The First Takeoff From a Ship

Hampton Roads, Virginia. November 14, 1910. The USS Birmingham sat in the harbor with an 83-foot wooden ramp bolted to its bow. The ship was supposed to be steaming into the wind to give Ely extra airspeed over the deck when he launched.

It was not.

After hours of waiting through ceremonies and a building squall, Ely decided he had waited long enough. He pushed the throttle. The Curtiss rolled down the ramp and went off the end before the Birmingham was underway. He dropped. The wheels hit the water, digging a trough in the harbor. Then he was flying - barely - the propeller chipped from the impact, shaking from the vibration.

Two miles later, he put the aircraft down on a beach near Willoughby Spit.

He had just taken off from a ship for the first time in history.

The Harder Problem: Getting Back On

A takeoff requires speed and lift. A landing requires getting rid of both in a very short distance. On land, an aircraft rolls out over a thousand feet or more, the runway absorbing energy over distance.

On the platform rigged for the Pennsylvania, Ely had 120 feet. After that, San Francisco Bay.

Chambers, Curtiss, and Ely developed the solution together. Twenty-two ropes were stretched across the platform, spaced roughly a foot apart. Each rope was weighted at both ends with sandbags draped over the edges of the deck. Hooks fitted to Ely’s undercarriage would catch the ropes on rollout. As the sandbags dropped and dragged, they absorbed the aircraft’s kinetic energy. The more ropes caught, the faster he would stop.

The system was tested ashore before the ship attempt and confirmed it worked on the ground. Then it went on the deck of the Pennsylvania.

Ely also had flotation bags fitted to the aircraft. If nothing worked, he was going into the bay, and the preference was to find him alive.

January 18, 1911: The Landing That Proved Everything

San Francisco Bay. January 18, 1911. The morning fog had cleared enough to fly. The Pennsylvania sat at anchor, with roughly 10,000 people lining the surrounding shores and crowding the naval vessels in the harbor. Mabel Ely, Eugene’s wife, stood on the deck of the Pennsylvania.

There was a complication. Because the ship was at anchor rather than underway, she was not pointed into the wind - she was sitting broadside to it, the wind pushing sideways across the platform.

Ely lifted off from a temporary field at Selfridge Point on the shore. He flew a circuit over the bay, lined up his approach, crossed the water, crossed the stern of the ship, and dropped onto the platform.

Eleven ropes caught the hooks. The sandbags dragged. He rolled forward, his propeller kissing the deck as the nose dipped at the end of the rollout. He stopped.

The crew of the Pennsylvania sprinted across the deck. Mabel Ely came through the crowd, found her husband, and kissed him in front of everyone.

The wardroom fed him lunch. Then Ely went back out to the aircraft - which the crew had turned around and repaired as best they could - and took off from the platform, flew back to Selfridge Field, and landed.

First shipboard landing in history. Hot lunch. Gone.

Captain Chambers wrote in his report that the experiment had been a complete success and that the feasibility of shipboard aviation was now beyond question.

Why This Moment Built the Entire Carrier Era

The sandbag-weighted rope system was the direct forerunner of every arresting wire on every aircraft carrier ever built. The underlying physics - using momentum transfer to stop an aircraft in a short distance - does not change. Materials improve, engineering refines the concept, aircraft get faster and heavier. The proof of concept happened on the deck of the Pennsylvania.

The USS Langley, the Navy’s first aircraft carrier, was commissioned in 1922 - converted from a coal transport ship, slow and ungainly. The men who trained on her became the carrier aviators of World War II.

By 1942, U.S. fleet carriers were operating in the Pacific. Coral Sea, Midway, Guadalcanal. By 1944, Philippine Sea and Leyte Gulf. Carrier aviation was the decisive weapon of the Pacific war. Every pilot who flew off a carrier deck in those years was building on what Ely proved over Hampton Roads and San Francisco Bay with a wooden platform and a pair of sandbags.

Eugene Ely Did Not Live to See Any of It

Ely died on October 19, 1911 - nine months after landing on the Pennsylvania. His aircraft stalled during an exhibition at an airshow in Macon, Georgia. He was 25 years old.

Mabel Ely spent decades advocating for her husband’s recognition. She wrote to the Navy, contacted historians, and kept his name in front of people when it might otherwise have faded. The Navy recognized him formally in the years that followed - the kind of recognition that tends to arrive after what someone proved becomes so foundational that everyone wants to claim they understood it all along.

There is a building at Naval Air Station Pensacola named for him. The carrier aviation community knows what his flights meant. But Ely does not carry the cultural weight of Lindbergh or Yeager - pilots who survived long enough to become legends in their own time, who had decades to tell the story themselves.

Ely had roughly two years of serious flying. He had two flights that changed how warfare works.

Every arrested landing since - that fraction of a second when the hook catches, the wire takes the load, and the aircraft decelerates from flying speed to stopped in roughly two seconds - carries his fingerprints.


Key Takeaways

  • November 14, 1910: Ely made the first takeoff from a ship, launching from an 83-foot ramp on the USS Birmingham at Hampton Roads, Virginia, before the ship was even underway.
  • January 18, 1911: Ely made the first arrested landing on a ship, catching 11 of 22 sandbag-weighted ropes on the deck of the USS Pennsylvania anchored in San Francisco Bay.
  • The arresting gear he used - hooks catching weighted ropes - is the direct ancestor of every carrier arresting wire in operation today.
  • Captain Washington Irving Chambers drove the Navy’s adoption of shipboard aviation against significant institutional resistance, correctly anticipating its strategic value.
  • Ely died in an airshow accident on October 19, 1911, just nine months after his historic landing, at age 25 - before the carrier aviation he made possible ever existed.

Sources: Naval History and Heritage Command archives; San Francisco Chronicle, January 1911; Henry Holden, aviation history research on early naval aviation.

Radio Hangar. Aviation talk, built by pilots. Listen live | More articles