Decision Altitude vs. Minimum Descent Altitude, the Floor That Decides Whether You Land or Go Around

Decision Altitude and Minimum Descent Altitude are the two floors governing every instrument approach - and confusing them can be fatal in low IMC.

Aviation News Analyst

Decision Altitude (DA) and Minimum Descent Altitude (MDA) are not interchangeable terms for the same concept. They apply to different categories of instrument approaches, they work differently in the cockpit, and the technique each requires is fundamentally distinct. The type of approach you’re flying determines which minimum governs your descent - and that shapes everything from your brief on the ground to your actions at the runway threshold.

Why the Approach Category Determines Your Minimum

Instrument approaches fall into three categories based on the guidance they provide.

Precision approaches - primarily the Instrument Landing System (ILS) - give you both lateral guidance via the localizer and vertical guidance via the glideslope. The glideslope beam, projected from near the touchdown zone at roughly three degrees, defines your descent path electronically to the runway. Precision approaches use a Decision Altitude.

Non-precision approaches provide lateral guidance only. A VOR approach aligns you to the final approach fix, but once inside it, no electronic signal defines your descent angle. The same is true of NDB and basic LNAV GPS approaches. Non-precision approaches use a Minimum Descent Altitude.

Approaches with Vertical Guidance (APV) are a third category made significant by WAAS-capable GPS receivers. The LPV approach (Localizer Performance with Vertical guidance) delivers certified WAAS-based glidepath guidance - not identical to a traditional precision approach, but to a standard that earns a Decision Altitude. Many LPV approaches publish minimums as low as 200 feet AGL, matching a Category I ILS. If your aircraft has a certified WAAS receiver and the approach offers LPV, fly LPV.

The older term Decision Height (DH) still appears on Category II and Category III ILS approaches, where radio altimeters are required and the measurement is explicitly tied to height above touchdown zone elevation. It’s the same concept as DA - just a different reference datum, and still found on those specific plate types.

What Decision Altitude Demands at the Moment It Arrives

The term is not metaphorical. When your altimeter reads DA, you are deciding - at that instant, with no pause permitted. Either required visual references are established and you are in a position to make a normal descent to the runway, or you execute the missed approach. There is no option to level off and evaluate. You are on a glideslope. You are descending. The decision happens at DA, not after it.

Proper technique is binary. The pilot monitoring calls “minimums”; the pilot flying responds with “continuing” or initiates the missed approach. The aircraft does not stop descending during that exchange. If visual reference isn’t present at DA, the missed approach is already underway while the words are still being said.

How Minimum Descent Altitude Works Differently

On a non-precision approach, you descend from the final approach fix to MDA and level off. FAR 91.175 prohibits descending below MDA until required visual references are established and the aircraft is in a position to make a normal landing. You fly forward at that floor altitude, scanning for the runway environment.

The traditional technique is dive and drive: descend efficiently to MDA, then drive level at MDA until the runway environment appears or you reach the missed approach point.

The missed approach point is a geographic or time-based location defined by the procedure - a VOR, a GPS waypoint, or elapsed time from the final approach fix. If that point arrives without required visual references, the missed approach is not optional. Flying past the missed approach point in IMC without executing the published procedure means the obstacle clearance guarantees built into that approach no longer apply.

This is one of the most common failure modes on non-precision approaches: a pilot reaches MDA, doesn’t see the runway, and continues forward past the missed approach point hoping something will appear. At that point, the aircraft is at low altitude in IMC, past the protected area, and the approach design is no longer protecting it.

What the Required Visual References Actually Are

FAR 91.175 specifies what you must see to continue below DA or MDA. The list includes: the approach lighting system, the threshold, threshold markings, threshold lights, runway end identifier lights, the visual approach slope indicator, touchdown zone markings, touchdown zone lights, the runway or runway markings, and runway lights.

One critical nuance: if the only thing visible is the approach lighting system itself, you may descend to 100 feet above the touchdown zone elevation - no lower. Approach lights confirm where the runway is, but they don’t provide enough reference to touch down safely. To go below that 100-foot buffer, you must see the red terminating bars or red side row bars of the approach lights, or acquire one of the runway-specific references directly.

This distinction has real operational weight. Seeing approach lights clearly while the runway itself remains obscured is a legal basis to continue from above minimums - but it does not permit descending below 100 feet above touchdown zone elevation until more is established. It’s a detail that gets taught on the instrument checkride and sometimes quietly forgotten.

GPS Approaches: Where LNAV, LNAV+VNAV, and LPV Each Fall

GPS has layered the minimums picture. Knowing which line on the plate applies to your equipment matters before the approach begins.

LNAV (basic GPS non-precision) uses MDA. Lateral guidance only; dive and drive applies.

LNAV+VNAV adds advisory vertical guidance computed from barometric altimetry. The navigator provides a computed glidepath to assist the descent, and minimums are often lower than the pure LNAV line. But because the vertical guidance is advisory - not certified - minimums are still expressed as MDA.

LPV provides certified WAAS-based vertical guidance. This earns a Decision Altitude, and minimums are typically significantly better than any LNAV line on the same plate.

Continuous Descent Final Approach: The Better Technique for Non-Precision

The FAA and most instrument training programs now endorse Continuous Descent Final Approach (CDFA) over traditional dive and drive. The concept: calculate a constant-angle descent profile from the final approach fix that would carry the aircraft to the runway threshold, and fly that profile continuously rather than stepping down and leveling off at MDA.

The safety case is clear. Dive and drive places the aircraft at low altitude, possibly in a configuration change, while the crew is scanning for visual reference under time pressure. CDFA maintains a stable, continuous profile. At the calculated decision point, if required references are established the approach continues; if not, the missed approach is flown. MDA is still the legal floor - CDFA doesn’t alter the published minimums. But flying a stable angle instead of a level crawl at minimum altitude substantially reduces workload at the highest-pressure moment of the approach.

Circling Approaches: Why the MDA Is Higher and the Risk Greater

A circling approach - flown when the instrument approach course isn’t aligned with the intended landing runway - uses MDA. Circling minimums are almost always higher than straight-in minimums, for a specific reason: the circling MDA is designed to clear obstacles across the entire maneuvering area around the airport, not just along the final approach course.

Circling minimums are also tiered by aircraft approach category, based on approach speed. Faster aircraft require a larger protected circling area, and typically face higher minimums.

The non-negotiable rule: if visual reference with the airport is lost after descending below circling MDA, execute the missed approach immediately. Not toward where the runway appears to be. The published missed approach procedure, without delay. Circling approach accidents follow a consistent pattern - the pilot loses visual contact in a turn at low altitude and attempts to find the runway. There is one correct response to losing visual reference while circling, and it is a missed approach.

The Decision Gap That Training Often Leaves Unfilled

The technical framework above matters. But the operational moment most likely to precede an instrument approach accident isn’t a knowledge failure - it’s a decision failure.

At DA or MDA, with the approach flown correctly and the runway somewhere just below, there is genuine pressure to find a reason to continue. A sliver of light might be an approach light. A dark shape could be the runway environment. The temptation to find something, anything, is real and well documented across accident reports.

What that moment requires is a pre-committed answer. Before the approach begins - in the brief, on the ground - the question should already be settled: If I’m at minimums and I’m not certain what I’m seeing, what do I do? The answer should be decided before it needs to be executed. If the answer isn’t clear at that moment, the missed approach has already been chosen.

The minimums on that plate were calculated using TERPS (Terminal Instrument Procedures Standards) criteria, designed specifically to clear terrain and obstacles with a defined margin. That number was not chosen arbitrarily. It was built to protect an aircraft that follows the procedure. The protection ends the moment the aircraft descends below it without established visual reference - or presses past the missed approach point still searching.

Pre-committing to a missed approach when uncertain is not conservative flying. It is what disciplined instrument flying looks like.


Key Takeaways

  • DA applies to precision (ILS) and APV (LPV) approaches; MDA applies to non-precision (VOR, NDB, LNAV) approaches - and the difference in technique is significant.
  • At DA, you are deciding at the moment of arrival; there is no leveloff. At MDA, you level off and fly forward to the missed approach point.
  • FAR 91.175 requires specific visual references to continue below minimums; seeing only approach lights permits descent to 100 feet above touchdown zone elevation, no lower.
  • LPV approaches with a certified WAAS receiver earn a Decision Altitude and typically offer the lowest available GPS minimums - always fly LPV when it’s available and your equipment qualifies.
  • Continuous Descent Final Approach (CDFA) is the FAA-endorsed technique for non-precision approaches; it reduces workload and risk compared to traditional dive and drive.
  • The most dangerous moment on any instrument approach is at minimums with uncertain visual contact. That decision should be pre-committed on the ground, not made in the cockpit under pressure.

Radio Hangar. Aviation talk, built by pilots. Listen live | More articles